Sunday, April 20, 2008

Response to Proposals

Students:

In general I have seen a lot of great comments and ideas flowing in your proposals and outlines. My first overall comment is that many of you need to be more systematic in your treatment of the essay, and you can do this in a number of ways. What I mean by systematic is that you need to deal with Durkheim's theory--which has multiple concepts that relate to each other--in an effective manner.
The most straightforward way to do this is to answer each question in order. This is absolutely acceptable. If you do this, remember that you still need to offer an OVERALL thesis up front. I've seen many of you put this in your outlines, which is good to see.

Alternatively, as you look over your notes and develop your answers, I encourage you to think about dealing with the totality of Durkheim's theory [as presented in readings and in lecture] and present your answers to part 1 without going through each question in order. This will be more complicated, but I think you have the tools to do so. For example, the first 5 essay questions themselves are designed to prompt you to think through all of the elements of Durkheim's ideas.

Either way, what I'm looking for is an introductory paragraph with an original, strong thesis in regards to the overall prompt. DO NOT REPEAT THE QUOTE IN YOUR ESSAYS:

“In the United States, the totem emblem is the flag.” -- Marvin and Ingle, Course Reader, p. 71.
Your job is to explain what this claim means and to select evidence that you think best illustrates how the flag functions like a totem.

Following this is where I expect you to have 2 or 3 sections. First, deal with the first 5 questions which are exclusively about Durkheim. Following this you need to deal with the final 2 questions, which you can do in 1 or 2 sections. This will probably depend on your thesis.


Now, in terms of specific issues, here are some comments that apply to many of the proposals I received.
Part 1
  • "Practical causes" are really society--don't confuse the two
  • What are the differences between the spiritual and material dimensions of a totem? Why must they have both elements?
  • Why must totems/symbols be external? How is that externality related to the totem's status as a group object?
  • Remember that Durkheim's theory is dynamic. So in addition to thinking how totems emerge in society, think about two other processes:
    • Why must totems be reinvigorated, and how is this done?
    • How do symbols continue to affect societies/clans after they are chosen?

Part 2
Keep in mind the following issues:
  • What are potential differences--or similarities--between the clan vs. nation, and totem vs. flag? Are these groups equivalent, analagous, etc--or are they significantly different? Either way you answer this affects the flag's role as a totem. Many of you offer your personal opinions without defending them with examples and evidence.
    • For example, many of you listed ways in which the flag is respected/revered in American society. You need to go further and show how these examples relate to the flag as totem, not just tell me how the flag is displayed or cared for.
  • Many of you called the U.S. a religious community or patriotism as a religion. If you make this argument, you need to offer evidence of why this is true. Just as if you disagree with this, you need to offer evidence of why its' not true.
In both sections I've seen evidence that you've started to work through Durkheim's theory, and have good ideas about the flag/nation, but now more work needs to be done to make your arguments more specific.

Friday, April 18, 2008

Essay Format

Students:

Let me explain what I expect in terms of the format of your essay as the prompt says to follow my directions.

First, and most importantly, I expect a thesis statement. This means you need to offer me an actual answer to the opening question of the essay prompt. In other words, even though you have to answer all the little questions, you also have to offer me an argument--your words laying out your thoughts. This should occur in the opening paragraph, and serve as an introduction to the subsequent points you are going to make.

Secondly, as for answering the 3 parts of the essay, I strongly suggest you have an initial section that works through the questions relating to Durkheim. You do not need to answer each question in a row, but I will be looking to see that you have indeed answered each and every question. I think a hint here is to look at Professor Biernacki's model of the cycle present in Durkheim's theory, which we recreated in part in section this week.
After that section THEN deal with the flag issues raised in the final two questions. I leave it up to you to answer these questions together or separately, but again you must deal with both.

Essentially, my main requirements are that you have a clear, strong thesis, and that you address Durkheim's theory first, and separately, from considering the flag as totem. Also keep in mind the three elements on which you will be evaluated. And remember you are not to rely on the argument made in Martin's article on the flag but use your own examples and analysis, per the prompt.

Best of luck, and we will work through any final issues on Tuesday.

Proposals

Students:

I sincerely apologize but I am not able to return your proposals today since I am not done providing feedback to all students. I will email you all individually over the weekend with my thoughts and I may post some collective pointers here as well.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Obama vs the Flag as Patriotism

Students:

If any of you watched the Democratic debate in Pennsylvania last night [I have to admit I only watched a little--I mean it is something like the 20th debate...] you might have seen this highly relevant question about Obama's relationship to the flag and patriotism more generally. And listen to how he, as Professor Biernacki suggested yesterday, offers himself as a new/reinvigorated symbol of America:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8PuKgW6YToU

And if nothing else, check out the wood paneling in that woman's house! Those of you who have never been to the Northern states are really missing out...

Monday, April 14, 2008

Nazis, Rituals, and the Olympics

Lest anyone think the current protests over the Olympic torch for the Beijing Olympics is desecrating the sacred nature of sport, consider the origins of the torch relay.

This article not only touches on the role of ritual and myth-making in the Nazi era [and again Riefenstahl is crucial to their production] but our own: one of the key reasons why protestors have challenged the torch across its journey is its extreme totemic significance to this day...

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/14/arts/14conn.html

If you want to know how the Olympic torch really began its “Journey of Harmony,” as the Chinese call its current relay, if you want to see why the torch has had to pass through a human obstacle course composed of protesters, SWAT teams and police in San Francisco, Paris and London, then do not look to Tibet’s grievances against China. Look to the opening of Leni Riefenstahl’s 1938 film, “Olympia.”


Bettmann/Corbis

Arrival in Berlin: The final relay runner brings the Olympic flame to the 1936 games.

In that homage to Berlin’s 1936 Olympic Games the origins of this ritual are revealed. Never before had a lighted torch been relayed from a Greek temple in Olympia to an athletic competition, let alone by thousands of runners trying to keep it from being extinguished.

So Riefenstahl creates the myth the Greeks never got around to telling, creating a filmic counterpart to the opening of Wagner’s “Ring,” in which an entire world gradually emerges from elemental fragments. The camera begins by surveying a misty landscape of ruins, of shattered pillars and overgrown grasses. Restless and circling, the camera reveals a Greek temple standing amid the stones. Heads and the bodies of Greek statues appear in an eerie erotic landscape. Under the sensuous caresses of Riefenstahl’s lens, a naked discus thrower comes to life, polished stone becoming muscular flesh. Another athlete prepares to throw a javelin, its trajectory leading toward a bowl of fire. Lighting the Olympic torch, another nude acolyte triumphantly raises it aloft like Wagner’s Siegfried displaying his sword...

Tomorrow's Section

Students:

I hope the extra readings have helped clarify Durkheim's ideas. I think Professor Biernacki has done us all a favor by making explicit Durkheim's theories over the past few lectures.

Some things to consider from the packet:
  • Why are animals chosen as totemic emblems?
  • What is the purpose of tattoos, and what is not?
  • What is an example of these "mysterious forces"?
    • How are they both external and within us?
    • How is their externality related to the choice of material objects as symbols?
  • Are there differences between how 'primitives' and contemporary members of societies experience rituals and collective representations? Why or why not?
    • Is our relationship to the flag different than a clan's relationship to an animal or flower? Either way, why or why not?
Tomorrow please remember to bring your 1 page, double-spaced proposal for your essay. We will use these to discuss Durkheim as well as this week's reading on the flag as totem.

Friday, April 11, 2008

Essay Prompt

Students:

For those of you who still do not have the prompt or prefer electronic format, here it is. Again remember that it is due at the beginning of class two Wednesdays from now, April 23rd.

Sociology 20 -- Prof. R. Biernacki
First Essay, Spring 2008

“In the United States, the totem emblem is the flag.” -- Marvin and Ingle, Course Reader, p. 71.

Your job is to explain what this claim means and to select evidence that you think best illustrates how the flag functions like a totem. Follow these steps:

1. How did Durkheim define a totem and why did he think totems emerged in societies? What are the objective forces that lend a totem its sacredness? What shows a totem is sacred? How does a totem help a society function?

2. What evidence is there that the U.S. flag is our totem? You may cite your own first-hand experiences, news reports on how Americans use the flag, and the Course Reader.

3. Do you think there are important differences between a totem and the U.S. flag? Why or why not?

Wherever possible, try to back up assertions in your essay with page references to the readings (or historical facts from lectures). You are not expected to do research, but if you happen to know of evidence apart from course assignments, you are free to cite it in your essay. You may cite lecture ONLY for historical evidence not found in the readings.

There is no single correct answer, as long as you show you can illustrate Durkheim’s theory of the totem in reasonable ways. In evaluating your essays, we will be looking at three dimensions: [1] the quality and consistency of the analysis, [2] the range and aptness of evidence that you use to back up your analysis, and [3] grammar and clarity of expression.

Your essay is due at the start of lecture, Wednesday, April 23rd. Please, do not write more than five double-spaced pages. Be sure to follow the format and style suggested by your T.A.